Tiffany Midge

         Tiffany Midge has a very dry, sarcastic humor. She does not overshare and invite the reader into

 parts of her life which would not be deemed socially acceptable. She does not center her humor around

 herself, but around white society at large. I feel like I compare everything to Samantha Irby, but only

 because Irby writes so flawlessly. Midge's humor differs immensely from Irby's. I see the value in

 Midge's humor, and her essays provide great representation for Indigenous Americans, but her comedy is

 not entirely inviting. It does not need to be! But in the articles about comedy having the ability to change

 the world, the caveat is that a wide audience needs to feel connected to the comedy in order to listen to

 the message. In my opinion, Midge's work does not do that. 

        Midge's goal does not seem to be to save the world with her comedy; it seems to just be

 representation for Indigenous Americans. This is also perfectly okay! In fact, her non-Indigenous

 audience then learns something while reading her work. Two of her essays from the second half, "Feast

 Smudge Snag" and "Eight Types of Native Moms" were clearly not written for a non-Indigenous

 audience. There were a lot of references I did not get (generationally, pop culture wise, and culture wise),

 and it made it a little bit more difficult to be engaged. Obviously Indigenous Americans should have a

 voice in comedy. However, the audience Midge writes for appears to be a mainly Indigenous audience.

 She differs in this approach from Irby, where Irby invites non-Black readers in to see that Black women

 are people too. Midge does a lot less of this bridge building, which-- again-- is totally okay, but is

 something that should be recognized. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Final Reflections

       One of the most exciting things I have learned throughout this class is the broad scale of healing and social action that can occur from humor and how the different types of humor weigh in to form a particular narrative around complex topics. Before taking this class, I had experienced people utilizing humor in their lives to talk about issues that might be weighing heavy on their minds or conflicts they need to get off of their chests, but I never did I imagine humor being associated with sexual assault; or racist stereotypes by individuals that have been victimized to heal their pain and move past their trauma. The articles we read for class regarding the role of humor in social change and sexual assault put the power of laughter into a new category for me where I had not yet recognized its purpose. The power of humor to heal should be shared by individuals who have been victimized to break down oppressive structures surrounding them.     ...
Read more

kalman

                There are big questions in Kalman’s   The Principles of Uncertainty.  She uses her art in tandem with handwritten passages in the style of diary entries. She questions (to name a few) the purpose of life, war, and death all in less than 400 pages. In the first section of Kalman’s work she presents the reader with a map of the United States—absurd and endearring in how wrong it is. Pennsylvania is down by Texas , Florida takes up the place where Maryland would be, and Hawaii (no longer an island) makes a new home in New England. As we read on, in Kalman’s handwritten font, she divulges that her mother drew this for her: “This is the world through her eyes” (9). She shares many different stories throughout her work, each feeling as ephemeral as the next. She doesn’t share (typically) the grandest story that each of the notable have but more so the “little” details of their lives: their friends, thei...
Read more

Principles of Uncertainty

  Sophia Starkey   Dr. Ellis EN 346D  19 March 2023 Principles of Uncertainty Response             The idiosyncratic inner monologue that Maira Kalaman presents is exceptionally relatable and incredibly touching. She constantly is in a tug of war with Time and what anything means if it all disappears one day. She recollects “the realization that (you/me) going to die and the attending DISBELIF- is not that the central premise of everything? It stops me dead in my tracks a dozen times a day. Do you think I remain frozen? No. I spring into action. I find meaningful distraction” (46). I, too, have had the inevitable dread about the deeper meaning of everything I am doing and how my worries and anxieties are nonsense because they cannot change a thing. Her mention of meaningful distraction is so prevalent in finding meaning and purpose. I, too, can appreciate the beauty and elegance of fruit platters or sitting in a ...
Read more